McArthur's Bakery

113 North Kirkwood Rd
Claim This Listing


I took a picture to this bakery thinking that I would not be able to get my dream cake that I had found on the internet. However, when I showed them the picture, they assured me they could do it. I was really nervous about it, but when I saw the cake on my wedding day I was SOOOO impressed! It was PERFECT!

3 stars for taste and value.

0 stars for service (TINA WAS HORRIBLE); Manager ended up helping us in the end.

Delicious cake. Amaretto flavor is to die for.

Awesome cake! So good and friendly staff! We changed our order about 3 times and they were so great about it! Our guests raved about our cake! The one bad thing about McArthur's is that you HAVE to go in to the store for every single thing. Of course go in for the intial ordering, but if you make changes, you have to go in and refill out the paperwork and everything in the store. We live in Illinois, so it was an inconvenience...

They delivered to an unusual venue, on time on a holiday which really impressed us. I was able to do my entire order via phone, fax and email, since I was planning from 1200 miles away. The customer service was amazing!!

Most importantly, the cake was DELICIOUS!

White chocolate and strawberry filling and some of the best buttercream ever!

Overall a wonderful experience!

Cake was amazing and I heard it tasted great- I guess I will find out on our one year anniversary!

To write a review, you must login first.

Similar Items

Casual Delights

Minette Rushing's Custom Cakes

Mulberries Cake Shop

Tidmarsh's Bakery